RealTime IT News

Index Helps Investors Sort Through Online Brokers

A reader sent an e-mail this week complaining about poor service from online broker Wit Capital, which offered its own IPO last Friday.

"I have an account there, and tried twice to buy IPO shares, but was blocked," the reader writes. Worse, he adds, "they never answer my emails, faxes, letters. If you call, you have to wait hours on the phone, then they say all they can do is take a message. Something is seriously wrong."

To be fair, it's not just Wit. I've heard and read complaints about service and slow transaction processing by several online brokers. While many online investors are happy with their brokers, others are still shopping around, trying their best to figure out which company should get their business.

The trouble is, barring their own personal experiences, most investors must rely on anecdotal evidence and (even worse) marketing claims to sort out the market.

Now an Internet performance measuring company has developed a weekly index that measures how fast 15 online trading sites complete stock buy orders and how easy it is to successfully submit an order. (Unfortunately, Wit Capital is not included in the listing.)

Keynote Systems' Web Broker Trading Index debuted this week with results from their analysis of online stock transactions conducted from June 1-4 in 10 major metropolitan areas.

The index shows that Dreyfus had the fastest processing time, at 7.47 seconds per transaction, barely ahead of runner-up Scottrade. On the other end of the list, laggards E*TRADE and Ameritrade turned in times of 38.35 and 37.44 seconds, respectively. The index average was 25.24 seconds per transaction.

In terms of transaction success rate - the ratio of successful to attempted transactions - the best online broker last week was Brown & Co., which completed 99.3%. Scottrade was runner-up in this category as well, with a 97.9% rate.

Suretrade was a disaster. Only 46.7% of attempted transactions on Suretrade by Keynote's program were successful, far behind even the No. 14 finisher, E*TRADE, which had an 80.5% transaction success rate.

(Keynote defines unsuccessful transactions as those in which any Web page fails to download completely or those that exceed a time limit of 12 seconds per Web page involved in the transaction.)

Obviously the index is a promotional tool for Keynote, which markets e-commerce measurement, diagnostic and consulting services. But it also provides a potentially valuable research tool for online investors, and will serve as a reality check to online brokers carried away by their own hype. Other Web brokers will be added to the index in ensuing weeks (including, hopefully, Wit Capital).

Keynote, based in San Mateo, Calif., will keep weekly results of its broker survey postedon its Web site.


ALL NEW! internet.com's HotWatch a monthly e-mail subscription for $99, featuring Internet Stock Report's Steve Harmon, and his top 10 noteworthy Internet stocks for the month. Each month you will receive in-depth analysis on the top 10 Internet stocks to watch with the information you need to assess the fast-paced nature of Internet stocks. Staying on top of market changes in the Internet Stock market is what counts. For $99 per year, you receive 12 timely issues sent to you by e-mail. Don't wait, our next issue will be out before you know it with a whole new perspective on the market. Sign up today at: e-newsletters