Sen. Schumer Goes After Microsoft
Page 1 of 1
Microsoft Corp. sat down with Department of Justice (DoJ) officials and 18 State Attorneys General Monday to discuss settlement of the government's ongoing antitrust suit against the company. But now the software titan faces trouble on a new front as the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee -- goaded to action by committee member Sen. Charles E. Schumer (D-NY) -- has scheduled a series of hearings in September focused on Internet competition and Microsoft's Windows XP operating system.
Schumer also contacted Assistant Attorney General Charles James, head of the DoJ's Antitrust Division and asked him to ensure that any settlement the government reaches with Microsoft also include stipulations that the company end anti-competitive practices in Windows XP.
"I am sending a letter to the head of the Antitrust Division, asking that he not settle with Microsoft unless they agree to a global settlement providing open access for competitors to offer their software application products on an equal basis with Microsoft applications," Schumer said.
In his letter to James, Schumer said, "In building Windows XP, Microsoft appears to have hardwired preferences for Microsoft applications over those produced by competitors. It seems that Microsoft intends to maximize its monopolistic power, using XP to enter new lines of businesses -- such as digital photography, media players, and messenger services -- while limiting the choices consumers have. Without open access, the fundamental principles of a free market are violated, innovation is stifled, and consumer welfare is harmed."
Schumer's stance is an about-face from his previous position on the case, as he himself noted in a letter to Microsoft Chief Executive Officer Steve Ballmer.
"As you know, I have been a supporter of Microsoft Corporation, particularly during the many challenges it has faced in the last year and a half," Schumer told Ballmer. "I believed Microsoft to be a consumer-friendly company that, having created the dominant operating system platform for the technology revolution, deserved its success, and I often stated so publicly. I was also vocal in questioning whether the break-up of Microsoft was a fair and appropriate remedy. I believe I was one of the few in my Party to be so supportive of Microsoft."
So what prompted Schumer to change his mind? Constituents. Eastman Kodak Co. and -- following the merger with Time Warner -- AOL Time Warner are both New York companies.
"As the company readies to launch its newest product, Windows XP, Microsoft is about to lose my support," Schumer told Ballmer. "In a number of markets, and specifically in the case of two New York companies -- Kodak and AOL Time Warner -- I have observed Microsoft engaging in what appear to be anti-competitive practices, and my views on the company are swiftly changing. I can now relate to the level of frustration evident in Judge [Thomas Penfield] Jackson's rulings."
Schumer said Windows XP prevents users from accessing applications from competitors, like Kodak's digital imaging software, by requiring users to instead work through Microsoft's "Scanner & Camera Wizard" before accessing non-Microsoft imaging applications.
"It seems that the very design of Windows XP is hardwired to preference Microsoft's application," Schumer wrote.
He also said he was concerned by reports that Microsoft insisted AOL no longer offer the RealNetworks RealPlayer media player as a condition of bundling AOL's software with the operating system, and that it was hardwiring its new instant messaging platform, Windows Messenger, into the operating system.
To paraphrase Microsoft's response: Phooey! Microsoft said it is in fact Windows XP that embraces the principals of user choice and partner opportunity while AOL Time Warner pursues a closed, proprietary strategy.
Jack Krumholtz, director of Federal Government Affairs and Associate General Counsel of Microsoft, in a response to Sen. Schumer, also said New York State is home to 50 businesses that are developing Windows XP products and is home to more than 20,000 Microsoft partners.
On the issue of the Scanner & Camera Wizard, Krumholtz said to Schumer, "Digital camera vendors supporting an industry standard (PTP) no longer need worry that consumers will be blocked from uploading digital images from a camera to a computer that does not have the camera vendor's proprietary software installed. The Windows XP Scanner & Camera Wizard provides basic photo acquisition and manipulation capabilities for every Windows XP consumer. That said, Windows XP makes it easy for any photo acquisition software vendor to write its software to present itself as an option for any vendor's camera when it is first connected. With a simple click of a box, a consumer can set that application as the default whenever that camera is connected in the future. This offer is presented to the consumer on complete parity with the Scanner & Camera Wizard the first time such a camera is connected."
As for Schumer's problem with the addition of Windows Media Player, Krumholtz said, "Media player functionality has been included in Windows for many years, and Microsoft is proud of the latest innovations it will release with Windows Media Player for XP. Microsoft's player and media formats are far more open than the leading competitor [RealPlayer] due to Microsoft's broad licensing of these formats to its competitors. As a result, competitive media players, such as RealPlayer, can play content created in Microsoft's formats, while Microsoft has not been provided with similar compatibility for those competitors' proprietary formats, including RealPlayer's. In line with that closed competitive philosophy, AOL Time Warner has adopted an exclusive approach in offering its customers only one vendor's technology: RealPlayer."
On the issue of Windows Messenger, Krumholtz said to Schumer, "Not only can every Windows XP user communicate in real-time audio and video with every other user over the Internet, but other great new features like real-time application collaboration and remote assistance (which permits more experienced users to help their friends and family with their computer by providing a view of their computer remotely) provide the kind of innovation that AOL Time Warner has not delivered. Windows Messenger will also enable many other great consumer service companies, such as eBay, to deliver notifications and other helpful information in real-time to their millions of customers. As you know, Microsoft has urged AOL to open up its closed instant messaging system so that they could interoperate with others, but despite public commitments to the contrary, AOL has steadfastly refused."
Krumholtz also argued that it is critical to the United States PC industry that Windows XP launch on time, and said Microsoft will work with Schumer and other congressmen to resolve concerns.