RealTime IT News

The Fallout from MobileStar

MobileStar Network Corp.'s troubles foreshadow an omnious tone for a nascent Wi-Fi technology, but analysts warn against writing off the 802.11 wireless standard just yet. Still, they also predict that this week's developments with the Richardson, Texas-based wireless Internet service provider will affect many future business models and may have service providers and equipment vendors alike re-evaluating their rollout plans.

On Wednesday, word leaked out that the company, which has been attempting to build a broadband wireless ISP with nodes across the country, was closing up shop. A deal to fund more development fell through at the last moment, a MobileStar director told Reuters on Friday.

While the fate of the Richardson, Texas-based wireless Internet service provider now dangles in the hands of its investment advisor, Diablo Management Group, others are quickly re-examining their strategies. The remaining handful of service providers will likely adopt a specialized approach, industry observers said. And everyone from service providers to equipment makers would be wise to concentrate more on the enterprise market rather than consumers. In fact, while the MobileStar postmortem continues to be debated, one thing is for certain -- the future of the IEEE 802.11 technology depends largely on how wireless local area networks (WLAN) are accepted within the enterprise, analysts concurred.

"I think there has to be the critical mass in the corporate space first to proliferate the wireless technologies that people have in their laptops, because it only makes sense that a current user of wireless technology will want to extend the use from the office to the public space market," said Kurt Scherf, vice president of research at Parks Associates, a Dallas-based market research and consulting firm.

The Business Approach Matters
To the undiscerning eye, MobileStar appears to have a business model very similar to that of Wayport, from Austin, Texas. Both service providers hope to bring high-speed Internet access to the business traveler by serving hotels, conference and meeting centers and airports. But look deeper and the differences become apparent -- facets that Wayport is more than eager to point out.

"Our business model and strategy has been very different from theirs," said Dan Lowden, vice president of marketing at Wayport. "We fully expect to be a leader in this space in the long term."

First, Wayport approaches the business traveler with a variety options from wireless to wired access. That's not to say that wireless providers are facing a no-win situation. Lowden admitted that standalone wireless can be a successful business model. "You just have to have the right formula to make it successful," he added.

But perhaps the biggest discerning factor between the two Texas wireless ISPs is the age-old B-school adage: Know thy customer. MobileStar offered a variety of pricing plans from pre-paid service to unlimited local to unlimited national to per-minute. Its service plans were tailored to meet the different needs of the business traveler but, at the end of the day, the customer was still the John Q. Public.

After stumbling around with consumers for a few years, Wayport, however, quickly realized that they needed to re-examine their business model and align with partners that were able to absorb some of the hefty start-up costs. So, rather than incur the upfront capital expenses and recurring charges, Wayport shifted some of the initial costs to the hotels. In essense, the hotels became the customers. The two partners have been sharing revenue ever since.

Given analysts' predictions, that approach may be the only model that works.

"I don't think anyone can be cash flow positive until 2003. That's simply because there's a lot of upfront costs with building out the infrastructure...setting up the access points," said Navin Sabharwal, vice president of Residential & Networking Technologies at Allied Business Intelligence.

There's WLANs in Them Their Hills
MobileStar's downfall is also attributed to the tough task of trying to be all things to all people. "I think it might make more sense to take a regional approach or take [an industry-]specific approach like with American Airlines Admiral Clubs. You can give the consumer the impression there are enough locations for the consumer to connect. You're making a much more conservative business model," Sabharwal said.

To be sure, Wayport's rollout strategy encompasses a national scope.

"People are still looking for the service. We have hotel properties that know they have to have this type of service. They are losing business if they don't," Lowden said, explaining that less than 10 percent of hotels nationwide have high-speed Internet connections -- wired or wireless.

Still, there is consensus among the industry. Everyone from analysts to participants now believe the so-called "Gold-Rush" mentality is dead and that first-mover advantage doesn't amount to a hill of beans anymore. It no longer makes sense to acquire customers "at any cost" and, for this reason, many see MobileStar's collapse as a watershed event for a nascent industry.

"If you look at the cellular companies, there's a reason there's roaming. I don't see why people doing this aren't taking the same approach. In the last six months, there was a 'land-grab' mentality. If they took a more reasonable approach, they probably could have preserved cash," Sabharwal said.

"A 'land-grab' is the way the industry used to be," Lowden added. "Those days are gone...it's not a short-term or long-term model that works."

As for the equipment makers, most are staying quiet about MobileStar's impact until the fallout can be better examined. Executives from Intersil, Lucent, Texas Instruments and Symbol Technologies all declined requests for interviews stating it was still very premature.

And analysts like Sabharwal believe equipment makers will be shielded from any fallout for the time being. "The MobileStar implosion will be fairly well-contained to the 'Public Hotspots' space. The equipment suppliers will still depend on enterprise acceptance. Public networking wasn't going to be a big market for them."

"It's the same sort of argument for the home...wireless will come as long as you have enough users in the corporate environment," Scherf added.