Browser Tools Need to Grow Up

You might say that Web developer tools for presentation layers have cut a
couple of new teeth with offerings such as Macromedia’s
and Microsoft’s latest Visual Studio beta additions.

But it’s not like those tools will help Web user interfaces chew through
complex applications anytime soon.

For all the expectations we have about advanced business transactions over the Web, the latest tools — as good as they may be — tell us the industry has some growing up to do before presentation layers can handle the rich applications and data exchange we now expect.

Analysts such as Mark Driver, a vice president and research director with
Gartner Research , have been beating the drum about this trend for
some time.

Today, Driver explains, the gap remains between the two worlds of Web
development. On one side is the traditional fat client GUI
that helps provide a rich user experience — that spiffy “look and feel” we
all expect.

On the other side of the development gap is the traditional Web model,
which provides amazing reach, but skimps on its ability to support
consumer and on-demand corporate deployments. Business intelligence? CRM?
This is great stuff. But it’s frustrating when a page takes
forever to load because the presentation layer is chewing up — make
that gumming up — too much bandwidth.

In the meantime, a new application model from third-party vendors is
emerging, one that Driver says will help address the gap between the fat,
but rich, client/server UI model and the thin, but poor, Web-based UI model. He
calls it Rich Internet Application, a platform that will address the best
elements of both. Ultimately, the tools will evolve past the page-based,
document-centric HTML foundation that rules the browser-based applications.

Infragistics is one such vendor that provides tools to help developers
build these UIs quickly.
Its products keep developers from getting bogged down with plumbing
questions about the
presentation layer, so they can think about the business
logic that goes into the middle layer.

For example, the company’s NetAdvantage 2004 Volume 2 allows developers to build
commercial-quality UIs for Windows Forms, ASP.NET, Tablet PC and COM. And it doesn’t matter if they’re working in a .NET or Java shop. The toolset offers style presets
across all ASP.NET elements, as well as MSDN-style help through HelpCenter. It also
includes new features in
WebTab, WebGrid, WebCombo, WinSchedule and WinGrid in addition to the
introduction of three new elements:
WinDataSource, GridBagLayoutManager and FlowLayoutManager.

Dean Guida, Infragistics CEO, says the idea is to cut down the
time spent developing the presentation layer in a development cycle. With a
presentation layer strategy, he says, you get a consistent interface across
applications in an enterprise.

“One thing we’ve heard from developers and project managers is that
people want this thin-client capability to be able to deploy on the
server,” Guida told But here we are at that
gap again: what is unacceptable are all the round trips to the server in a thin-client

This is one reason for so many performance bottlenecks in Web
environments and why too many of us are drumming our fingertips on our desks
waiting for the page to load. That’s why Infragistics’ NetAdvantage has
implemented a client-side API to help reduce the message load.

Keep in mind, too, that HTML was never designed to be used as an
application interface. With the rise of the Web, it has been appropriated
for that purpose,
but it was never more than a document format, Driver says. Using HTML for
what it wasn’t designed for
has skewed features, as well as design-thinking, to page-based metaphors.

Even with XHTML, a lot
of this stuff works just fine, Driver says. You can even buy tools
for this, and you can
create a cool look and feel on the presentation layer using only JavaScript
Dynamic HTML. But then it becomes a problem for developers to

Plus, he adds, “If I’m a company
that sells shoes, etc., do you really want to spend a lot of time building
low-level plumbing, particularly with Internet development or traditional
client development? When developers get mired in the infrastructure and
plumbing, they start to lose sight of what they wanted to do: build a
business application.

“We see this a lot in enterprises,” Infragistics Guida added. “Developers have to play a lot of catch up with the need to build and re-tool. A lot of companies want to build a service-oriented architecture. They need the ability to reuse and retool on the front end of the
presentation layer. Companies are continually trying to re-use that, to
reuse this data and logic.”

ASP.NET tools, and Visual Studio for that matter, are offering this
ability, but there’s more room to grow.

“Vendors are focusing on providing a set of technologies, components that
allow you to get a richer user experience,” Driver says. “We’re starting to
see other [vendors] start to deliver these.” So you see companies
providing these sets of user
interface components that give you tremendous amount of bang for the buck.

Plus, development teams pretty much maintain a code base for one dominant
browser: IE. That may be changing with the rise of Mozilla and other
browsers. But still, more than one code base is too costly. So
we will miss a lot across different browsers until richer, high-fidelity
development for one
browser platform can translate to another.

That’s why declarative UIs are the critical aspect and necessary toolset
to fill this gap. Driver noted that declarative UIs will move the model itself to
become a set of blueprints, such as an XML text document, which will be
shipped down to the computer and windowed on-the-fly while controls
will also be built. That helps cut down on bandwidth and CPUs, which
will help the presentation layer.

Microsoft’s Avalon features in Longhorn, it’s next generation of Windows,
as well as its XAML language, will be building on these declarative UI
tools. But that won’t be for a few more years. And that’s why, for now at
least, third-party vendors are moving in to fill the gaps while presentation
layer tools build their chops.

News Around the Web