As more telephone companies begin offering Digital
Subscriber Line technology to their customers, a new advocacy group is
being launched to promote competition and affordable pricing in the
high-speed Internet market.
The High Speed Access Coalition, or HiSAC, said it will act on behalf of
households, home and office businesses and telecommuters who can only gain
high speed data services through one company, usually a local Baby Bell.
The group is hoping to spur competition among data service providers to the
home market, in the hopes of shattering what it terms “the last remaining
HiSAC said although several start-ups who offer DSL service have asked Baby
Bells to share local phone lines, the Baby Bells and Independent Local
Exchange Carriers (ILECs) are thwarting competitive access. The group said
DSL service provided by regional Baby Bells, such as U.S. West and SBC,
charge monthly rates that are as much as double the price charged by
“Millions of Americans want affordable high-speed Internet access for their
home, but they’re being held hostage by the Baby
Bell companies that are trying to preserve their monopoly control over data
services for the residential market,” said David Wilson, HiSAC’s executive
director and general counsel.
HiSAC said The Federal Communications
Commission as well as the California Public
Utilities Commission (PUC) are now evaluating whether Baby Bells should
provide the new DSL companies with equal access to the local phone
networks. Fearing uninformed and hurried rulings, the group said public
interest and consumer groups must act to stave off monopolization.
“This is about monopoly power over the ‘last mile of copper’ for home
access to high-speed Internet service,” Wilson said.
“Consumers have their choice of several long distance carriers and mobile
phone services, but they still have only one choice
when it comes to DSL service. The FCC and California PUC must avoid a rush
to judgement until consumers have had a fair opportunity to make their
According to HiSAC, ILECs have long insisted that the newer companies known
Local Exchange Carriers (CLECs) must provide
both voice and data service, and calls this “a tactic that unnecessarily
raises the price that consumers would have to pay and has forced
many of the original CLECs to focus on providing DSL and telephone service
to the corporate market, where competition is more open.”
“Just as consumers don’t have to switch phone companies when selecting a
long distance carrier, they should be able to select a data service company
that is different than the company that provides their voice service,”
The advantages of opening up the DSL market to more balanced competition,
HiSAC said, will enable consumers to benefit from much lower charges.
“If consumers are ever going to receive the cost benefits that competition
brings, the federal government and states need to
open up local phone lines to innovation and spur competition,” Wilson said.
“Although each company would establish its own rates, HiSAC projections
show that proposed rates are considerably lower
than cable access or DSL access through existing local phone companies,”
In the burgeoning high-speed market, DSL is poised for considerable growth.
David Cooperstein, senior analyst at Forrester Research predicts that by
2002, there will be 2.2 million ADSL users and that consumer spending on
DSL access will reach $770 million dollars.
“Right now the market is very localized, although WorldCom just announced
plans to launch DSL nationwide with start-ups Northpoint and Covad.”
Currently Covad and Northpoint compete against Baby Bells PacBell in
California and Bell Atlantic in the East.