UPDATED: The U.S. Supreme Court Monday dealt Research in Motion (RIM) another serious
setback in its long-running patent infringement battle with NTP, denying the
developer of the widely popular BlackBerry a high-court review of the case.
was seeking a decision of the validity of U.S.
patent laws on the Canadian-based company, which maintains its principal
servers in Waterloo, Ontario.
“RIM has consistently acknowledged that Supreme Court review is granted in
only a small percentage of cases and we were not banking on Supreme Court
review,” Mark Guibert, RIM’s VP for corporate marketing, said in an e-mail
statement to internetnews.com.
In a press release issued shortly after the decision, the company said, “RIM
sought review because it believes the case raises significant national and
The Supreme Court did not. The case now goes back to the U.S. District Court
in Virginia, where RIM faces a possible shutdown of its U.S. service and a
settlement with NTP for as much as $1 billion.
“The Supreme Court’s denial closed the final path for RIM to avoid
liability,” NTP said in a statement.
The Virginia court must decide whether to reinstate an injunction against
U.S. sales of the BlackBerry. Last November, the same court supported
the Virginia-based NTP’s efforts to reject a $450 million proposed
settlement with RIM.
U.S. District Judge James R. Spencer said the term sheet entered between RIM
and NTP in March 2005 to settle the litigation is not an enforceable
“Today’s [Supreme Court] order has no bearing on the merits of the
outstanding issues in the [Virginia] case,” RIM insisted in its statement.
The November ruling allows NTP to continue moving forward in the case,
including the reinstatement of a 2002 injunction that “prohibits RIM from
selling, using or importing into the United States infringing BlackBerry
hardware and software until the last of the litigated patents expires in
NTP said in November any injunction would not affect the usage of BlackBerry
products by federal, state or local governments or by first responders. RIM
claims if NTP prevails in gaining an injunction, it has software workarounds
to keep its popular products in U.S. hands.