A year after winning a landmark U.S. Supreme Court case against Grokster,
the recording industry is back in court pursuing LimeWire, a popular
peer-to-peer (P2P) music file sharing service prospering in the place of
In a lawsuit filed Friday in New York, the Recording Industry Association of
America (RIAA) sued LimeWire for “staggering” copyright infringement.
The RIAA lawsuit seeks a permanent injunction against LimeWire’s P2P
operations and compensatory damages of at $150,000 for each copyright
infringement. In addition, the RIAA wants unspecified punitive damages.
“The scope of infringement caused by [LimeWire] is staggering,” the RIAA
“Millions of infringing copies of [the music industry’s]
sound recordings have been made and distributed — copies that can be and are
permanently stored, played and further distributed by LimeWire’s users.”
The RIAA contends LimeWire’s actions are hurting the legitimate online
market for downloadable music.
“Despite numerous efforts to engage LimeWire, the site’s corporate owners
have shown insufficient interest in developing a legal business model that
adequately respects copyrights,” the RIAA said in a statement.
“While other services have come productively to the table, LimeWire has sat
back and continued to reap profits on the backs of the music community,” the
RIAA said. “That is unfortunate and has left us no choice but to file a
New York City-based LimeWire did not respond to either telephone or e-mail
requests for comment on the lawsuit.
In MGM v. Grokster last summer, the Supreme Court ruled
companies are responsible for the illegal acts of their users.
decision was a significant victory for movie studios and music publishers
seeking to stop the widespread theft of copyright material over file-sharing
The decision broke Grokster, which agreed
in November to cease operating its network and distributing its file-sharing
Last month, Australian-based P2P company Kazaa agreed to
pay a reported $100 million to the trade organizations representing the
international music industry.
Over the last two years, several P2P
companies have converted their operations into legitimate services.
The most notable of the P2P companies going legitimate is Napster, the
original P2P company forced into bankruptcy under legal pressure in 2001.
Napster has since reinvented itself with legal downloads and a music
“Since the Supreme Court’s unanimous Grokster decision last year, we have
extended our hand to the major illegal file-sharing networks and encouraged
them to become legitimate players in the online music marketplace,” the RIAA
“We have been patient as a number of services — WinMX, Bearshare, Grokster,
i2hub, Kazaa — have ultimately decided to close down or transform
themselves into legal music services.”