SCO Appeals Decision to Limit Claims Against IBM

SCO is appealing a recent ruling that would strike down nearly two-thirds of
its claims in its ongoing legal battle against IBM over alleged
misappropriated portions of Unix code.

The filing follows a June decision
by Utah district court Judge Brooke Wells who ruled in favor of granting
IBM’s motion to eliminate 187 of the 294 SCO claims due to a lack of

Judge Wells’ ruling is seen by many as a major blow to SCO’s legal battle
with IBM, in which SCO alleges
that IBM in some way misused its Unix software license and inappropriately
shared Unix trade secrets with the Linux development community.

SCO  spokesperson Blake Stowell confirmed to that SCO filed an appeal to the federal court but
said SCO would not comment on its contents because it was filed under seal.

An IBM  spokesperson declined to comment on SCO’s
appeal, noting that IBM does not comment on legal actions in progress.

SCO made a redacted version of the appeal available, outlining its
protestations to Judge Wells’ ruling in 60 pages.

In the filing, SCO argues that it complied with the court’s direction to
identify misused material with specificity. SCO also argues that it did not
willfully refuse to provide information.

“There is no basis in the record for the Magistrate Judge’s conclusion that
SCO willfully — that is, intentionally — refused to provide the source code
information IBM contends it was obligated to provide,” SCO’s appeal states.

“To the contrary, the record evidence shows that SCO provided all the
identifying information it had regarding the ‘misused materials’ at issue,
and there is no evidence SCO is holding anything back.”

Judge Wells’ original ruling included harsh words that took aim
at SCO’s alleged lack of disclosure.

“Given the amount of code that SCO has received in discovery, the court
finds it inexcusable that SCO is, in essence, still not placing all the
details on the table,” Judge Wells wrote in the original ruling.

The case is expected to go to a jury trial in February 2007.

News Around the Web