A federal judge in Los Angeles ruled yesterday that online file-sharing
company StreamCast was guilty of “massive copyright infringement.”
The verdict gives the entertainment industry a full sweep in its battles
against file-sharing companies Grokster, Kazaa and now StreamCast.
U.S. District Judge Stephen Wilson granted the plaintiffs’ summary judgment and
denied StreamCast’s motion for a continuance, writing that “evidence of
StreamCast’s objective of promoting infringement is overwhelming.”
A spokesman for StreamCast expressed disappointment in the verdict and told
internetnews.com that “an appeal is certainly an option.”
He said that the company still hasn’t had an opportunity to review the
StreamCast maintains that it “did not encourage users
to infringe on copyrighted works and never intended to do so,” the spokesman said.
Judge Wilson disagreed with that contention.
“Infringing use was indisputably on StreamCast’s mind when it developed
Morpheus; indeed StreamCast took steps to ensure that the technology it
deployed would be capable of infringing use,” Wilson wrote in his 60-page
The Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) reacted to the verdict
“No single court ruling solves piracy or can make up for several challenging
years for the music community, but there’s no doubt that this particularly
important decision means that the rules of the road for online music are
better today than they were yesterday,” it said in a statement.
The StreamCast spokesman said the company intends to continue promoting its
Morpheus multi-tasking software.
“Morpheus is an innovative, multi-use program with legal uses that are
overwhelming. In the meantime, Morpheus will continue to discourage users
from infringing upon copyrighted works,” he said.
But if the fate of other defendants in this suit is any indication,
StreamCast may be running dangerously low.
Kazaa, owned by Australian-based Sharman Networks, settled in
July, agreeing to pay music industry trade groups $100 million and to
implement filtering technology to prevent future illegal file swapping on