Typically, deposed witnesses must swear to tell the truth, the whole
truth and nothing but the truth. But what about “truthiness”?
The issue could come up, now that Google
announced it intends to
depose Stephen Colbert, the host of Comedy
Central’s Colbert Report, as it
defends itself against a billion dollar copyright lawsuit from Viacom.
Colbert is perhaps best known for his adherence to truthiness in
his satirical views on politics and American culture. He joins John
Stewart, host of Comedy Central’s other hit program The
Daily Show, on a list otherwise loaded with executives, company
founders and lawyers.
Google’s list of witnesses, filed in a U.S. District in New
York, includes Viacom majority owner Sumner Redstone, Viacom CEO
Phillipe Dauman, Viacom General Counsel Michael Fricklas and others.
Viacom’s list includes Google founders Larry
Page and Sergey Brin, YouTube founders Steve Chen and Chad Hurley,
Google CEO Eric Schmidt and 23 others.
Colbert and Stewart likely join the list of executives due to their
one-time popularity on Google’s video-sharing site YouTube, which Viacom alleges Google uses to “promote and profit from massive
copyright infringement of television programs and feature films on an
unprecedented scale,” as a copy of the filing obtained by
A Google spokesperson told internetnews.com the filing is in
practicality a negotiation document and that many of those named will
not end up providing depositions. Viacom declined to comment.
Viacom and Google are in court to decide which
of the two companies should bear the cost of keeping Viacom’s
copyrighted content off YouTube.
Viacom seeks $1 billion in damages.
To defend itself, Google will rely on section 5.12 of the Digital
Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). Google will argue the DMCA
protects Internet companies like YouTube from being held liable for
the copyright infringement of its users and that the law
makes viable a wide range of Web 2.0 businesses that would be
overburdened by the cost of policing their users.
Viacom, however, believes that, although the DMCA provides some
Internet companies “safe harbor,” companies that profit from
copyright infringement and could do something to stop it are not
guaranteed protection by the law. It argues that if Google’s
interpretation of the DMCA were made law, copyright-holding content
creators would lose incentive to work.
Third-party depositions will begin Nov. 7. Viacom and Google depositions start March 7, 2008.