Last week, Stallman published an editorial accusing Amazon (AMZN)
of threatening the freedom of e-commerce through its one-click patent.
That’s the system Amazon uses for storing shopper’s credit card and shipping data so
they can make subsequent purchases with the click on a button.
Amazon has sued competitor barnesandnoble.com,
for copying the idea. And the company defended its aggressive legal actions by saying it invested
thousands of hours in developing the software behind one-click.
But Stallman insists the patent office has made a mistake and believes Amazon’s
invention is so obvious it doesn’t deserve a patent.
“The reason I’m concerned with this is that it affects the freedom of
everyone who wants to run a Web site or might conceivably want to run a Web
site,” he said. “It’s not just about barnesandnoble.com, and basically its
an irrelevance how many hours it took them to write the software because the
details of that software is not the issue.
The question is whether (Amazon.com) should be allowed to forbid me to spend
the necessary hours to write my own software to do this job.”
While some Amazon defenders admit the patent system is broken, particularly
as it applies to Internet business method patents, they also say the company
is just playing the game and has no choice but to use patents as a
But according to Stallman, U.S. patent law was created to promote progress and
the common good of society, not to reward inventors with riches. And he says
that while Amazon’s actions make be perfectly legal, that doesn’t mean
“I don’t believe that any thinking being, any being capable of knowing right
from wrong, deserves an exception from ethics, and that includes the
officers and stockholders of Amazon,” Stallman said.
“The whole point of a boycott is that it’s something you can do when a
company has done a lawful action you disapprove of. If we only wanted to
criticize illegal actions, we wouldn’t have to use boycotts. We could use
lawsuits or prosecution.”
Amazon has said it’s aware of the boycott but hasn’t detected any impact on
To put extra pressure on the company, Stallman is now calling on Web site
operators to post a boycott notice on their Web pages with a link
to a page at the gnu.org Web site, operated by the Free Software Foundation.
He’s also asking book
authors to post a message about the boycott in the authors comments section
that Amazon creates for every book at its site.
Last week, Stallman himself submitted such a message for three of his books
that are carried by Amazon. He says the comments have yet to be approved and
posted by the company.
“Most likely they’re not going to post it because they say that they screen
them all,” he said. “They say that they have guidelines. And while the
guidelines don’t explicitly say, ‘no criticism of Amazon,’ I suspect that
they’re just not going to post it.”