What is good for Time Warner (TWX)
is not good for America Online Inc. (AOL).
As everyone knows, AOL and Time Warner decided to merge yesterday. The
new combined AOL will have a market capitalization of a staggering $350
billion. It’s the biggest merger in corporate history.
Shareholders of Time Warner loved the deal. The stock soared 25-5/16 to
90-1/16. The Net efforts of Time Warner have been spotty, such as with the
disaster with Pathfinder.com. Although, as of late, the company has done
much better. Examples: CNN.com, CNNfn.com, CNNSI.com, etc. However, by
joining forces, crusty Time Warner has now entered the wired world.
As for stock AOL? Well, shareholders were not impressed. The stock fell
1-7/8 to 71-7/8. And there is good reason for AOL shareholders to be
First of all, one bad sign is the new name of the company: AOL Time
Warner. Why not just call it, simply enough, AOL? Well, I’m sure there
were many huge egos involved in the decision.
Just imagine the meetings with such a cast of characters as Steve Case,
Gerald Levin (chief executive officer of Time Warner), Ted Turner, Bob Pittman (AOL’s chief
operating officer) and so on.
If anything, the new name really means that there will be much confusion
about the value of the new company. Is it a new media company? Is it a
traditional publisher, movie studio and cable company? What is it really?
Next, there are likely to be many cultural issues. These are different
organizations and may not integrate very well.
True, there are definitely strong synergies. Time Warner has marquee
content — movies, music, magazines, etc. — that can be integrated into AOL.
There can also be cross-promotions among these properties.
What’s more, the AOL-Time Warner deal will likely incite other similar
mergers. It may, in fact, get crazy. One idea: Yahoo! purchasing Disney
However, I think the merger means that the long-term growth prospects of
AOL have slowed. It is not a fast-charging New media company.
It is a hybrid. AOL will now be hit with brick-and-mortar dilution.