It used to be that words like “portal,” “infrastructure” or “content”
would come up when the topic was an Internet public offering. These
days, however, it seems you’re just as likely to hear language such as
“loyalty programs,” “points,” “awards” and “incentives.”
That’s because in the past few weeks we’ve seen an onslaught of IPOs
from Internet-based direct marketing companies. The latest is
Netcentives, which began trading Thursday under the Nasdaq symbol (NCNT).
Offering 6 million shares at $12 each, Netcentives saw its stock open at
$13 1/2, straying as low as $12 1/4 and as high as $14 1/4 by early
Unless something changes, Netcentives appears headed for an inauspicious
debut. Which puts it in familiar company, for none of the recent IPOs
from Internet direct marketing companies have been greeted warmly by
investors, as the chart below shows:
|Company||IPO Date||Offer Price|| Closing Price|
|FreeShop.com (FSHP)||Sept. 28||12||13 9/16|
|Webstakes.com (IWIN)||Sept. 24||14||11 1/2|
|Yesmail (YESM)||Sept. 23||11||13 1/16|
|Cybergold (CGLD)||Sept. 23||9||12|
|MyPoints.com (MYPT)||Aug. 20||8||11|
Since their IPOs, all of these stocks have remained in close range of
their first-day closing price.
Why the across-the-board antipathy among investors? Probably because
they are having trouble distinguishing between the various players.
The basic business model for nearly all Internet direct marketing
companies is similar – attract people with promises of free stuff,
special offers or “points” toward a prize in exchange for their
patronage or demographic information that is sold to participating
companies looking for targeted marketing lists or e-commerce sales. And
partner with high-traffic Web properties.
(Oh, don’t forget to throw in a lot of exclamation points on your Web
site. In fact, maybe we should refer to public offerings from Internet
direct marketers as !Pos.)
Netcentives main program is the ClickRewards Network, which rewards
consumers with frequent flyer miles when they buy stuff online through a
participating company. Web sites that belong to the ClickReward Network
include barnesandnoble.com (BNBN), E*TRADE (EGRP), macys.com, OfficeMax.com and
Preview Travel (PTVL). Begun in March 1998, ClickRewards has more than 2
million members, according the Netcentives’ S-1 filing.
Netcentives had only $647,000 in revenue in 1998, though in the first
six months of this year revenue has jumped to $3 million. (Net loss also
has increased from $14.1 million in ’98 to $16.1 through Q2 this year.)
Those revenue figures are in line with the other companies listed above.
At the top is Webstakes.com, with $4.8 million in ’98 revenues, followed
by opt-in e-mail player yesmail.com, with $4.6 million, and then
FreeShop.com ($1.3 million), MyPoints.com ($1.3 million) and Cybergold
Hard for an investor to pick a market leader here. Actually, there is
one, but it’s none of the above. Xoom.com (XMCM), one of the first players in
the Internet direct marketing sector, had $8.3 million in sales in 1998
and $10.9 million in this year’s first two quarters.
The company claims 10 million subscribers, and was the 14th most-popular
Web property in August, attracting 9.1 million unique visitors. In
contrast, MyPoints.com, the runner-up among Internet direct marketers,
was ranked No. 36 with 4.1 million unique visitors. None of the others
cracked the top 50.
Investors recognized Xoom.com’s superior positioning when the company
went public on Dec. 9. Offered at $14 per share, XMCM stock opened at
$31 and closed even higher at $34 7/16, a 146% first-day gain.
Since then Xoom.com has traded as high as $98 =, and was selling
Thursday afternoon at $59 3/4.
With a $1.1 billion market capitalization, Xoom.com is valued at
anywhere from three to five times more than its half-dozen competitors listed above, making it the direct marketer to beat for now.
ALL NEW! internet.com’s HotWatch a monthly e-mail subscription for $99,
featuring Internet Stock Report’s top 10 noteworthy Internet stocks for the
month. Each month you will receive in-depth analysis on the top 10 Internet
stocks to watch with the information you need to assess the fast-paced nature
of Internet stocks. Staying on top of market changes in the Internet Stock
market is what counts. For $99 per year, you receive 12 timely issues sent to
you by e-mail. Don’t wait, our next issue will be out before you know it with a
perspective on the market. Sign up today at: e-newsletters